|
Children
The Silent Victims of Domestic Violence
Who
will speak for them?
Children
who witness domestic violence are themselves victims of abuse. Unless
directly abused, they are often overlooked and do not receive adequate
services. The children of battered women must contend with the same myths
and untruths about battering which confront their mothers. They must also
deal with adult prejudice which tells them, "Its not so bad...dont
worry. Everything will be all right." Meanwhile, everything they
feel and have experienced is bad.
Many
parents minimize or deny the presence of children while the mothers are
being assaulted. However, interviews with children of battered women reveal
they have seen and heard, and can give detailed accounts of violent behavior
that their mother or father never realized they had witnessed. Events
can be witnessed in many ways, not just by sight. Children may hear their
mothers screams and crying; the abusers threats; sounds of
fists hitting flesh, glass breaking, and wood splintering; cursing and
degrading language. Children also witness the consequences of the abuse
after it has occurred their mothers bruises and torn clothes,
holes in walls, broken furniture, their mothers tears. They sense
the tension in the house, and in their mother.
Caught
In The Crossfire!
Many
fathers inadvertently injure their children while throwing furniture or
other household objects when abusing their partners. The youngest children
sustain the most serious injuries, such as concussions, or broken shoulders
and ribs. These children also suffer poor health, low self-esteem, poor
impulse control, sleeping difficulties, and feelings of powerlessness.
They are at high risk for alcohol and drug use, sexual acting out, running
away from home, isolation, loneliness, fear and suicide.
- Yearly, 3.3 million children in the US, between 3-17 years of age,
are at risk of exposure to parental violence.
- In general 70% of men who abuse their female partners also abuse their
children.
- More than 50% of child abductions result from domestic violence.
- Abusive partners use children as pawns in custody fights to coerce
their partners to reconcile with them. Often, these coercive incidents
occur during court ordered visitation.
- Childrens lives are frequently disrupted by moves to escape
domestic violence. They lose considerable school time; flee home without
books, money, or changes of clothing; and live in the family car when
shelters are unavailable.
- Among children who witness abuse, 40% suffer anxiety, 48% suffer depression,
53% act out with their parents, 60% act out with siblings.
It
is important to educate multidisciplinary professionals in attending to
the ethical principles of beneficence, autonomy, and justice in dealing
with these children. Children who witness violence at home must receive
top priority in the allocation of scarce resources. Diagnostic screening
and assessment efforts must incorporate standard questions about family
violence into mental health and school counseling interviews. Sensitive
intervention and referral, linking victims and witnesses with intervention
specialists, will do much to limit the sequelae often seen with family
violence. Nurses must advocate for and support primary prevention programs
in elementary and secondary school systems. If we look at nothing else
except the number of children entering shelters because of domestic violence,
then it seems imperative that we recognize who these children are, what
they have survived, and what it is they need from us.
Violence
and the Older Adult
The
U.S. population has an increasing number of older adults. One health problem
often unrecognized in this aging population is elder abuse. Statistics
uncover a frightening picture of elder abuse in this country. The National
Aging Resource Center on Elder Abuse estimates the incidence of abuse
in domestic settings (not institutions) at approximately 2 million cases
per year. However, because this is still very hidden, it is difficult
to determine the exact scope of the problem. Researchers estimate that
only 1 out of 14 incidents of elder abuse actually comes to the attention
of law enforcement or human service agencies.
Elderly
people can be victims of neglect or physical violence; verbal, sexual
or psychological abuse; or financial exploitation. The problem may worsen
as the population of elderly Americans multiplies. By the year 2020 people
over age 65 will number about 52 million, almost one-sixth of the total
population. Those aged 85 years or older are the fastest growing group.
This
abuse seems to be related to the inability of one party to meet the care
demands required by the elderly, by him- or herself, or by the situation.
It also seems to be related to an inhibiting dependency between the parties,
a negative execution of power over the weaker, and a history of violence.
More than two-thirds of older abuse perpetrators are family members of
the victim, typically serving in a caregiving role. Victims often have
no outside support, and may live with intergenerational family violence.
At greatest risk are the frail and/or isolated. We must recognize the
seriousness of the problem and take steps to prevent it.
Reporting
Elder Abuse
Reporting
suspected elder abuse is simple. Call your local Long-Term Care Ombudsman
or local law enforcement to report abuse in a long-term care facility,
such as a nursing home or board and care home. Abuse occurring anywhere
other than a long-term care facility should be reported to the county
Adult Protective Services agency (APS). But, if you suspect abuse that
seems to be life-threatening, dont hesitate. Call the police or
sheriffs department. They will notify any other agency that may
need to be involved.
Victims
of Domestic Violence
All
individuals with evidence of trauma need to be questioned directly about
the potential for domestic abuse using a structured, nonjudgmental, confidential
interview conducted in privacy and safety. Current recommendations
include routine screening of all female patients over age 14.
Recognizing
Signs & Symptoms
In
addition to the obvious signs listed below, be alert to the presentation
of stress-related complaints such as headaches, or stress-enhanced conditions
such as chronic upper respiratory problems or bronchitis.
- Physical Abuse: Trauma/pattern of injury inconsistent with event history;
delay in presentation.
- Emotional or Sexual Abuse: Adults frequently present with complaints
associated with long-term stress and chronic anxiety. Children or adolescents
may present with behavioral problems. The elderly may present as withdrawn
or fearful of authority.
- Neglect: Lack of attention to person or environment.
Patterned Injuries: Central injuries to the face, head, neck, breasts,
abdomen, and genitals are prevalent in contrast to accidental injuries
affecting the periphery or extremities. A pattern of multiple non-
- ife threatening injuries at varying stages of healing is highly suspicious.
In children and the elderly, spiral fractures may be indicative of abuse.
Pregnancy: Escalation of domestic violence is seen in pregnant women
with up to 35% of obstetric patients suffering some type of physical
assault.
Screen
for batterers, too. The batterer may be our patient in some circumstances,
and treating contributing factors can help stop abuse. A batterer may
suffer from depression, chemical dependency, or post-traumatic stress
disorder, for example. Past head injuries have also been associated with
pathological jealousy and violence. Empathy, rather than a confrontational
approach, may make the batterer more amenable to treatment.
Prevention
and Intervention Strategies
Initial
Assessment
- Recognize potential victims; take your time to establish rapport,
and ask direct questions about domestic battering. Simple and specific
is best.
- Implement your agencys DV protocol if domestic violence is suspected
- Triage for immediacy of need for treatment
- If injuries do not require immediate trauma or surgical care, take
history from patient alone in private room
- If injuries require immediate trauma or surgical care, call security,
local police, or both if partner seems disruptive or dangerous
- Contact victims advocacy representative and offer services to
client as available
Examination
- Have patient undress and put on exam gown so that all areas of the
body can be visualized
- Check pattern of injuries
- Document the actions and demeanor of patient and partner. Use direct
quotes of their comments to you. Be as objective as possible.
- Document physical assessment findings in detail; any evidence of injury
from potential battery should be recorded on a body map and described
in a quantitative manner
- Record visual evidence of abuse via Polaroid or video recording, and
make sure your documentation is consistent with the pictures. If photography
is used, include full body views (anterior/posterior). Separate photos
for each injury site using a 90 degree angle and include an object for
scale or size (ruler, coin, etc.). Written consent of the victim may
be needed.
- Conduct mental status examination
- Use open-ended, nonjudgmental questions; never imply blame or ask
why
- Recognize potential evidence; collect, preserve and maintain chain
of custody
If
your client answers NO, or will not discuss the topic:
There
are many reasons a person will deny abuse. Be aware of some of the clinical
findings that may indicate abuse. It is reasonable to suspect abuse if
some of the following clinical findings are present:
Recurrent trauma history; injury to the head, neck, torso, breasts, abdomen
or genitals; bilateral or multiple injuries; unexplained injuries or injuries
that are inconsistent with the explanation given; delay between the occurrence
of the injury and seeking medical treatment; behavioral cues such as depression,
suicide ideation, anxiety and/or sleep disorder, panic attacks, symptoms
of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, alcohol/substance abuse problems; chronic
pain symptoms of which no etiology is present; and a partner that seems
overly protective, controlling or will not leave the womans side.
What
Should You Do if Clinical Signs are Evident?
If
any of the clinical signs are evident, and there are negative responses
to the screening questions, it is appropriate to ask additional questions
to prompt information such as:
- Sometimes when I see an injury like yours, it is because someone hit
them. Did that happen to you?
- I dont know if this is a problem for you, but many women I see
are dealing with an abusive relationship, so Ive started asking
about domestic violence routinely.
Victims
of Crime
You
must recognize that every battered woman is the victim of a crime. Battered
women are also frequently sexually assaulted and raped by the batterer.
According to Harvard Medical School research, counting acts by both partners,
8.7 million American couples (nearly one out of six) experience violence
each year, and 3.4 million experience severe violence.
Research
states that the most serious danger is physical injury or death. In fact,
up to 25 percent of all homicides in the United States are committed by
a husband or wife. All states have legislated criminal sexual assault
statutes and approximately 49 states have marital rape laws.
According
to studies completed at outpatient clinics, violence by husbands occurs
in more than 50 percent of couples seeking marital therapy but it is often
overlooked by therapists. One of the reasons is that wives spontaneously
responded on the written forms that aggression was a major problem in
their marriages. When a victim of domestic violence is present for treatment,
there are certain responses and assurances she really needs. Consistent
with information concerning domestic violence is the fact that survivors
need reassurance from you. Some examples of reassurance include:
- She is not a crazy person.
- She is not alone; there is help available.
- Domestic violence is a crime and she is a victim.
- No one deserves to be beaten.
- Her accounts of abuse are believed.
- There is hope that the cycle of violence can be broken.
- There are specific places and organizations where she can go for help.
Nurses
and other caregivers often ask if there is a typical profile of the violence
victim. Insofar as a "typical" profile of a domestic violence
victim, there has never been one established. However, it is a fact that
the victims of domestic violence are usually women. Old, young, white,
black, married, single, professional, unemployed, rich, poor, all are
potential domestic violence victims.
Children
are also victims in a battering environment even if they are not physically
abused themselves. When children witness violence between their parents,
they may learn violence as a way of life and later become involved in
abusive relationships themselves.
Help
for Victims of Domestic Violence
The
violence your patients are experiencing will not simply go away no matter
how often they wish or pray it will. Neither will it simply get better.
Once it has started, it will recur more often and each time it will get
progressively worse. It does not matter how much they love their partner.
They must know they are in danger of losing their life and need to take
steps to assure their own safety.
If
they want protection, the first step must be taken by them. There
are many people and places she can call, so she must gather her courage
and make a call for help. She can call a friend, family, or the police.
She can also call her church, a physician, or a counselor. There are also
womens centers, shelters and family crisis centers. They are always
open and she will be able to reach them by phone. Family crisis centers
have hotlines and are open 24 hours a day, every day. If she is unable
to find the family crisis center, call the police, sheriff, district attorney,
public library, or Salvation Army. The Salvation Army has kind and caring
people who will help without regard to color, religion or ethnic background.
They will put her in touch with people who offer exactly the assistance
needed. She must not stop until help is obtained. Her very life depends
on it.
What
to Do if You Become A Victim of Domestic Violence
Below
are some practical steps that you can teach victims or suspected victims
of abuse.
If
your abuser has left the house but you think he may return, you should
either leave or call a friend to come and stay with you. However, if your
abuser is still in the house and you think he may batter you again, you
should call the police or leave as soon as possible. It will take a lot
of courage to leave the house but it may save you from a future filled
with repeated acts of violence. You may want to tell the police you would
like to be taken to a womens shelter or some other safe place, or
you may prefer to ask them to tell you the location of a shelter, so you
can go there on your own.
If
you believe you are in danger, leave your home and if there are children,
take them with you. Even if you must leave in the middle of the night,
it is better than possibly subjecting yourself to more beatings.
If
you are unable to leave, ask someone you trust to stay with you. Develop
an "exit plan" in advance for you and your children. Know exactly
where you could go, even in the middle of the night and how to
get there. Pack an "overnight bag" in case you have to leave
in a hurry. Include toilet articles, medications, an extra set of keys,
clothing, and a special toy for each child.
When
you decide to leave, whether for a short time or permanently, be sure
to also take the following items: drivers license or some acceptable type
of identification card, money, checkbooks, credit cards, address book,
Green card(s) for immigration verification, your and childrens birth
certificates, title to your car, lease, rental agreement, house deed,
bankbooks, insurance papers, pictures, medical records for the whole family,
social security cards, welfare identifications, school records, work permits,
passport, divorce papers, jewelry and other valued items.
It
will be a good idea to gather these in one place as you are thinking about
leaving so you can obtain them if you need to leave in a hurry. Remember,
you can legally take anything that belongs to you alone and anything that
belongs to you and your husband together. You can withdraw money you have
in a joint bank account with your husband or partner. You may not take
anything that belongs only to your husband or partner. You may not destroy
property that belongs to both of you or only to your husband or partner.
If
you do not take everything you need when you leave, you have the right
to ask the police to escort you back to your house later to pick up the
items. The police can only allow you to take items that obviously belong
to you or your children, such as clothing. If you can, it may be more
convenient for you to wait until your partner goes to work or leaves the
home for some other reason and then go into the house and get what you
need. If you go back and your husband or partner wont let you in,
the police cannot force him to let you in without a court order.
Once you move, if you are concerned your attacker may try to find you,
be careful to whom you (or your children) give your new address and phone
number. You should consider renting a post office box or using the address
and phone number of a friend.
Be aware that addresses are a part of restraining orders and police records.
If you go to court, you should consider using only your post office box
or perhaps using your lawyers address as your own. This can be extremely
important if your partner has threatened your life or you believe he will
attempt to find and abuse you later.
If you are a nurse or other caregiver and you are experiencing a battering
relationship, there is help available to you. There are numerous shelters
available to women who are being battered or otherwise abused. In spite
of what you may have been told, these shelters and family crisis centers
do not act to break families up. Rather, they work to save lives and often
provide counseling services to the batterer or have the information to
direct them where they can receive help and assistance.
Advocacy:
Empowering the Victim
"Empowerment
advocacy believes that battering is not something that happens to a
woman because of her characteristics, her family background, her psychological
"profile," her family of origin, dysfunction, or her unconscious
search for a certain type of a man. Battering can happen to anyone who
has the misfortune to become involved with a person who wants power
and control enough to be violent to get it." Barbara
Hart, Seeking Justice: Legal Advocacy Principles and Practice.
The
primary goal of intervention is empowerment. By sharing your observations,
by agreeing that whats happening is wrong, just by listening in
a warm and accepting way, you give the victim strength and determination.
Many victims are relieved at the opportunity to tell the truth instead
of constantly covering up. You may learn that youre the first person
to confirm that her feelings of hurt and anger, the desire for support
and change, are normal. Perhaps most important, you will have supported
the patients independence and autonomy as a decision-maker and helped
her to recognize her strengths and resources as a survivor.
One
gesture in helping her carry out her decision is to give her the address
and telephone number of the nearest family crisis center. Additionally,
if you should find evidence of severe or frequent marital violence, immediately
evaluate the danger, especially the danger of homicide. Try to find out
if guns or other weapons are available to either partner. Investigate
the possibility of alcohol or drugs and establish if they are used by
the couple. Also consider the involvement of third parties, especially
if they are children.
Healthcare
professionals have been challenged to design effective anti-violence strategies
as a part of health care reform. Nurses who have knowledge about violence
can make a significant contribution to this challenge.
Thoughts
and Decisions
Despite
the fact that crime in general is leveling off or decreasing in the U.S.,
incidents of domestic violence continue to increase. The problem remains
immense, and while much of societal violence lies outside the healthcare
profession, there remains a major role, if not a responsibility, for all
nurses and healthcare providers to prevent our young from learning violence
as acceptable behavior and to intervene where violence is causing physical
and emotional injuries to our patients. The fruits of our commitment will
come when we, as nurses, treating patients one at a time, make a difference
by breaking the cycle of violence that engulfs peoples lives.
National
Help and Information Sources for You and Your Client:
National
Center on Child Abuse: 1-800-4 A-Child
National
Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-SAFE (Emergency 24 Hour)
National
Center on Elder Abuse: 202-682-2470
After
we receive your completed test, we will send a detailed packet of helpful
information concerning domestic violence and the profile of the abuser.
Also included are the long-term effects on the victims, and nationwide
resources to obtain help for children, adults and the elderly who have
been abused.
We
hope this course has helped provide you with a better understanding of
the causes of abuse, how to recognize a person who has been abused, and
the hope that it can be prevented with your intervention. You, as a healthcare
professional, are in the best position to provide assistance for the victims
who otherwise may not, or cannot, or are too afraid to, seek the help
they need to stop the abuse.
Battering
Violence Power Control Denial
Anger Coercion Threats Intimidation Emotional
Abuse Manipulation Isolation Blaming Harassment
Addictions Aggression Anxiety Fear
Grief Guilt Trivializing Ignoring...
Battering
is always a choice
|